A while ago I was asked to show some evidence for my cynicism about the delivery of Kickstarter-funded video games, that it was a site (to steal someone else’s quote that I now can’t find) where the unaware fund the unprepared. I couldn’t see that anyone else had done it, so I created this spreadsheet that lists all successfully Kickstarted video games since 2009. I’ve included video games and gaming peripherals in that list, but any “fund this gaming event / blog / new site” items have been ignored (because they are really a whole separate other area).
So let’s answer the question: do video games that are Kickstarted actually deliver the title they are promising (from 2009 up to the end of October 2012)?
But First: Caveats
I’m sure some people will look through that list and spot mistakes – titles I’ve missed, numbers I’ve got wrong, projects that have updated since I looked at them. This data was collected by manually scraping the data off the Kickstarter pages and the official pages of the title / studio in question. Sometimes there was conflicting information about an estimated release date. The list was started over a month ago and it is a bit hard for me to check all 300+ entries to see what’s changed every time I look at the sheet. Any mistakes I’ve made are a case of human error, not intentional alteration of data.
It also only includes titles that were classified by Kickstarter as “Video Games” – if a video game title was only classified under “Games” I’ll probably have missed it.
If you let me know of any errors or issues, I’ll look to update the spreadsheet and analysis.
The Kickstarter Boom
It’s pretty safe to say that Kickstarter blew up for video games in 2012. In 2009 only 5 video games were listed on Kickstarter and they managed to raise a bit over US$21k; in 2012 to October 31 there have been 207 listings that have raised over US$40.3m in pledges. That’s some massive growth.
Let’s look at that year-on-year:
You can also see that Kickstarted video games are overall attracting a lot more money than they have in previous years, but that’s due to a few projects going massive rather than lots of titles receiving large excess funds over their target. It’s important to note that despite the media attention put on the multi-million dollar Kickstarters, within video games the median amount raised per project is $10.7k.
If you want to refine that median to 2012 then it goes up to $14.6k in actual pledges, but that’s still not a lot of money for video game production. (Average Kickstarter success amounts are higher than that – $136.6k for the entire 2009 to 2012 period and US$194.6k to date for 2012 – but average results are substantially effected by outliers, which is something that Kickstarter video games have a number of.)
Another way to examine the skew of Kickstarter funding is to look how actual pledge totals are distributed. The ten most successful Kickstarted video game projects in 2012 – roughly 5% of ‘volume’ given there 207 successful video game Kickstarters to October 31 in 2012 – account for more two thirds of the 2012 funded total to date (roughly US$27.6m of US$40.2m). Shift that to look at the top 20 highest 2012 video game Kickstarters (i.e. 10% volume) and you account for 82% of actual pledges made.
If you look at a breakdown of how actual pledge amounts are distributed, you can see that despite the focus on US$1m+ (or even US$100k+) successful projects, the majority of successful video game Kickstarters are taking home less $20k or less.
Up to October 31 2012, only 7 projects exceeded that US$1m mark:
- Project Eternity
- Double Fine Adventure
- Wasteland 2
- Homestuck Adventure Game
- Planetary Annihilation
- Shadowrun Returns
To provide a bit more granularity to the distribution of project numbers I’ve also created two that show Kickstarter video game successes by month. Let’s start by looking at the number of successful projects:
Again, this just shows the growth in the number of Kickstarted video games reaching (and exceeding) their fundraising target. Right now Kickstarter is successfully funding 20 to 30 different video game projects a month. It will be interesting to see if that rate holds up. Kickstarters need people aware of them if they are to have a chance of reaching their pledge target and 20 – 30 new projects a month would seem to clutter things up relatively quickly.
I had tried to overlay the actual pledge amount raised onto the above chart, but the rapid growth in the dollar figures in 2012 throw everything out of whack. So here’s a separate chart that I’ve had to use a logarithmic axis (base: 2) to fit the dollar figures into a reasonable looking chart:
August 2012 hit the heights because the OUYA was funded then, account for US$8.6m of that sum. Even so, the Kickstarter video games section has been on an exponential climb for a while now.
Kickstand and Deliver
All of the above stats are interesting (well, to me) but they are only about how much of a boom Kickstarter has had with video games, not about how many video games have been delivered as promised following Kickstarter funding.
This is where things get a little tricky, since no doubt people will argue about the definition of ‘delivered’. I’m only considering titles that appear to have delivered on the majority of what their Kickstarter funded as ‘delivered’ and in most cases decided not to include anything with a backer alpha / beta on Desura or similar (unless that is all the Kickstarter pitch promised). If a developer promised a full copy of the game on launch, then that’s what I’m considering to be ‘delivery’. In some cases a developer has promised a title on two different platforms (say iOS and Android) but then only delivered on one; in those cases I’m considering the game delivered because it is out there and purchasable.
How well do Kickstarted video games deliver on their titles? About 1 in 3 since 2009:
It’s obviously too soon to tell if this trend holds true for 2012’s titles, but it does point to an issue that backers should think about seriously. Only 5 Kickstarted video game projects have been officially halted, but there are a lot of projects that stop providing updates or make announcements that the developers have “made the difficult decision to start rebuilding. From scratch.“. Delays in delivery are exceedingly common – the Kickstarted video games that are delivered are on average about 2 months later than the developers originally predicted.
Of those titles delivered, about a third are mobile games, which is also something to think about given that Kickstarter is often seen as the most appropriate for PC title development.
Where a released title is actually notable enough to be reviewed, overall review scores are generally positive, so at least Kickstarted video games are delivering a degree of enjoyment / quality if they are able to make it into the hands of gamers. Quite a few Kickstarter-backed projects languish in obscurity though.
The crucial test of Kickstarter video game delivery is from now (November 2012) up to March 2013. This period has 65 titles originally scheduled for release, including the Double Fine adventure, Tex Murphy – Project Fedora, Shadowrun Returns and the OUYA launch. If game studios can’t launch their titles within the time period indicated in their Kickstarter pitch, I can’t help but think that backers will become disillusioned and that pledge money will become a lot harder to obtain moving forward.
Cynicism Status: Intact and Holding
Getting an idea that 2 out of every 3 Kickstarter video game projects are yet to deliver (ignoring 2012’s efforts) isn’t something that has changed my mind on the topic of Kickstarter. I’m not really interested in letting someone else roll the dice with my money so that they can work on their dream project, especially when I’ve got the luxury of just buying the title at the other end if it ever launches. Backer rewards don’t really get to me (although some of the t-shirts have been fantastic – someone should licence and sell them) especially since Kickstarters have gone towards offering in-game benefits rather than real-world benefits… and as pointed out, only 1 in 3 titles actually get delivered.
Feel free to conduct your own examination of the data and come up with your own interpretations. At the very least you can use it to look up which Kickstarter video game project is due out next.
Pingback: [Links] Pandarian musings, Brawlers Guild, cash shops, SWTOR F2P « Welcome to Spinksville!
Pingback: What I’ve Been Reading: November 18, 2012 « Refrigerator Rants
Pingback: CHRISZAMANILLO.COM » This Week in Videogame Blogging:November 18th
Excellent analysis. I was not aware that there were that many projects (and so many high profile ones) scheduled for delivery in the first three months next year – that will surely be interesting times.
Personally, I suspect that the high-value projects backed by proven studios on proven concepts will work out; they may not deliver everything they promised, but they will deliver enough to make their “base” satisfied. There will be a lot of cognitive dissonance at work here, and backers will no doubt go a long way to justify their kickstarts as long as the delivery is not bungled completely. Projects like Ouya, Clang and others like them that break new ground…
Well, we shall see. Whether Kickstarter delivers on its promise or fails to hold up as a viable game development business platform, times will surely be interesting.
If some of these larger profile projects from those with established industry cred stumble / fail to deliver, then I think some of the gloss will come off. Those with industry experience obviously have the greatest probability of delivery, but then again a key question is around if those people will be disciplined enough to deliver on time and on-budget given that any time and / or cost overruns will potentially come straight out of the developers’ pockets.
For all the talk of “I just want to support the game concept!” that pops up from some circles, the vast majority of gamers want to actually see the game they bought into delivered.
I’ve been exploring ways to help people manage their crowdfunding ‘portfolio’ — keep track of what they’ve funded, discover new and interesting projects — and, given your cynicism (or is it skepticisim?) I’d be interested in chatting to you some time.
Let me know what you think!
I can be cyncial and skeptical at the same time if it helps! 🙂
Sure, I’m happy to chat, plus I’ve got some other Kickstarter-related articles in the wings that I’m working on.
Pingback: Только треть профинансированных игр с Kickstarter доходят до релиза | Sergey Galyonkin
Pingback: Около 70% игровых проектов на Kickstarter закрываются | Shiny Catz
Pingback: Kickstander: From Code Hero to Zero « Vicarious Existence
Pingback: Kickstander: The Doom That Came To Kickstarter, And The Transference of Risk | Vicarious Existence
Pingback: Post #400 | Vicarious Existence
Pingback: Kickstander: The List is Done. And Probably Already Outdated. Again. | Vicarious Existence
Pingback: Kickstander: Only Around A Third of Kickstarted Video Game Projects Fully Deliver To Their Backers | Vicarious Existence
Pingback: Kickstander: Another Look at Delivery Rates | Evil As A Hobby